
Welcome to DR. STU'S BLOG. Along with my podcast at www.drstuspodcast.com it is here that I post my thoughts on a variety of topics on the birthing world. Advocacy for true informed consent and respect for individual autonomy are the basis for the musings you will read here. I hope you enjoy while you learn and I encourage you to comment. Please check out www.birthinginstincts.com for information on home birthing with an obstetrician and my latest news and updates.
Monday, March 22, 2010
Micro vs. Macro:
Some of my dear friends are excited about the events on Capitol Hill yesterday. There are parts of the massive health reform bill that suit their agendas. Such is the case with the Mama Campaign people who have done really good work in improving access and payment to CPMs. Or, the portion of the bill that improves access to health coverage for those in need. Worthy objectives, yes. While this sort of "Micro" thinking may be personally satisfying for a worthy agenda I would like to caution my friends from too much euphoria. For, in my opinon, the "Macro" of this bill, the corrupted process by which it came to pass and the inevitable intrusion by tax, mandate or yet to be determined legal quandries into our lives, will make America worse off. Those of you who know me, know I cherish personal autonomy and responsibility over the collective. Soon to follow will come the poison in this pill. Restrictions on choices and mandates on behavior with unforseeable costs and debt from a class of elites whose leftist philosophy believes, truly, that they know best. Watch for ads on TV frightening you or seducing you. Soon to come will be the tax incentives or punishment for behavior that they think is good or bad. One size fits all is not an American value. For me, this assault on our individuality transcends political bickering. I don't trust big government. But you guys know that. Their track record at ruining things they touch is pretty good. American education is a good example. My point here is not to suggest how you should think. Only that it is important to think. As we fight for the causes we believe in don't forget to look up and outside at the bigger picture of where this confusing, massive mandate is taking us. Thanks, Dr F.
Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrups absolutely. - Lord Acton
ReplyDelete"Restrictions on choices and mandates on behavior with unforseeable costs and debt from a class of elites whose leftist philosophy believes, truly, that they know best."
ReplyDeleteWe already have restrictions on choices with the current system! Health insurance companies call all the shots. What doctor you can go to, how much they'll reimburse that doctor, what medications you can take and how much...
Mandates on behavior? Seriously? Again, this is already common practice. Insurance companies decline coverage to clients that are too 'risky' due to their alcohol or recreational drug use. Sometimes even due to their sexual practices.
Unforseeable costs? Like the current system where anyone can walk into an ER, give a phony name and contact info and get free treatment with the rest of us (society) left to pay the bill?
I'm all for Universal health care coverage and I don't feel this bill goes far enough. I don't think that I know best... and I certainly don't think politicians know best. I think YOU know best. YOU meaning the physician. I want a system where my physician can make decisions with me based on the best course of treatment. I don't want the government OR a private health insurer to call those shots. I believe this bill brings us one step closer to having health care regulated by the government. Regulated meaning it isn't a free for all for the private insurers.
"Insurance companies decline coverage to clients that are too 'risky' due to their alcohol or recreational drug use." - Sundance
ReplyDeleteAnd this is wrong because ?